News · News · Reported evidence
Madlanga allows questions on statement tied to Matlala’s collapsed plea deal
The commission rejected an objection to using the statement, while Matlala’s lawyers announced plans for an urgent review and he disputed its contents.

The Madlanga Commission has rejected Vusimuzi “Cat” Matlala’s attempt to prevent questioning on a witness statement linked to his collapsed plea agreement, ruling that the protection he relied on applies to criminal proceedings rather than the inquiry.
The decision on Monday, 9 November, allowed evidence leaders to begin testing the statement in public, the commission’s official transcript (opens in a new tab) records. Matlala’s legal team said it intended to seek an urgent High Court review, but commission chairperson Justice Madlanga declined to stop the hearing while that challenge was pursued. SABC reported (opens in a new tab) on Tuesday morning that questioning on the statement was continuing.
The dispute turns on section 105A(10) of the Criminal Procedure Act, which deals with what happens when a criminal trial starts afresh after a plea-and-sentence agreement falls away. Matlala’s advocate, van den Heever, argued that his section 204 witness statement formed part of those negotiations and could not be separated from the failed deal.
She told the commission that undertakings given during the negotiations protected the statement from further use. Allowing it to be used despite those assurances would undermine the plea-bargaining process, she argued.
Madlanga assumed, for the purpose of his ruling, that the link between the statement and the negotiations existed. He nevertheless held that the provision concerned the restarted criminal trial and did not bar the commission from using the statement.
Evidence leader Advocate Sello argued that the statement identified people whose accounts the commission needed to test and could provide grounds to call further witnesses.
Madlanga said the commission faced a real risk of running out of time to hear all the testimony it wanted. He would stop immediately if a High Court order set aside his ruling and interdicted the questioning. In that event, evidence already heard under the ruling would be treated as never having been heard, he said.
After lunch, Matlala’s counsel said he would proceed. He confirmed his signature on the statement but disputed parts of its contents. Evidence leader Adila Hassim invited him to identify and correct passages he disputed as they worked through it paragraph by paragraph.
Sources, evidence and corrections
- Madlanga Commission: 9 November hearing record (criminaljusticecommission.org.za) (opens in a new tab) · 9 November 2026
- Madlanga Commission: Matlala ruling (criminaljusticecommission.org.za) (opens in a new tab) · 7 November 2026
- SABC News: lawyer’s concerns over alleged meeting (sabcnews.com) (opens in a new tab) · 10 November 2026 at 11:45 SAST
Sources reviewed by the reporting and editorial desks on 10 November 2026. Consult the linked records for their full scope and later amendments.
