OPINION | The views expressed are those of Mzwandile Thakhudi. This contribution responds to Dr Zamani Saul and presents the author’s political argument on SACP electoral participation.
State power, popular power and the alliance
As a starting point, we have witnessed commendable theoretical engagements, grassroots mobilization, high visibility campaigns and organizing for two decades by activists within the YCLSA and the Party on the ideological commission in deliberations of the state and popular power question. It would be fallacious to suggest otherwise that the resolution on state and popular could be attributed to the suddenly emerging ‘’ ultra-left sectarian clique”.
The reply seeks to process accordingly the selective amnesia and denialism by Dr Zamani, reflecting on the current political conjecture and advocating for the reconfiguration of the alliance as a strategic task to rescue the NDR. He asserts that the resolution on state and popular power that has culminated into SACP independent contestation of elections commencing with 2026 LGE as a product of the 5th special national congress of which it is inaccurate and incomplete.
The SACP resolved to contest 2026 Local government elections in its 15th National Congress, the resolution book and the declarations of this congress are glaring as empirical evidence to this effect.
The discussions were anchored on the concrete analysis of the concrete conditions of the working class. These discussions were guided by the three watch words of strategic consistency, tactical flexibility and analytical alertness in order to purposefully evade being electoralist as the Party. This is far from what Dr Zamani characterizes as “revolutionary adventurism or adventurous act”.
Owing to his selective amnesia, it is convenient for Dr Zamani to forget the systematic veering of the track of the Path to Power, Ready to Govern and the Reconstruction and Development Programme. The subsequent gravitation to the neo liberal class project of GEAR, ASGISA, GIPSA macroeconomic framework. For Dr Zamani, this is “hard and complex work of governance” probably that does not demand the attention of other alliance partners.
It is easy to forget that the NDP, New Dawn and GAIN all advocating for the neoliberal agenda which seeks to stifle progress towards social emancipation and justice came from government to the organizational meetings. It is common cause that NDP was in force in August 2012 before it was presented to the ANC 53rd National Conference in December 2012. Is this not perhaps what Dr Zamani refers to as “top-heavy and disconnected” approach from grassroots struggles?
The assessment of the state of the National Democratic Revolution reveals the strategic ambiguity among the progressive forces and yields the revolution in cross roads, stagnant, in interregnum and facing strategic defeat. The reconfiguration of the alliance is indeed a prerequisite to the renewal of the alliance by refining the method of work to match the demands of the current conjecture. Is a common analysis of the state of the NDR, regular consultative seeking platforms too much for the alliance components to call for? Has there been alliance economic summit in recent times to process the plethora of economic policy trajectory we have traversed or we have outsourced the Harvard Scholars and IMF bureaucrats?
We look at the state of the socio-economic status of the working class, the black majority, the women and the youth. It is not dementia or amnesia but denialism to suggest that these economic policies do not have a bearing on the livelihoods of people as you look into the human development index. Take a look at the cost of living crisis, youth unemployment, underdevelopment, youth unemployabilty. The inequality is everdiverging unparalled levels as seen through gini co efficient. Could it be that the good Dr is aloof of all this glaring data?
The state of the two tiered health and education manufactures the crisis of inequality in education and health. The gender based violence and femicide, the violent communities that threatens safety of the public, peace and stability. Would the good Doctor really miss the correlations to the austerity budgeting for these ills?
All this reflect the writing on the Wall. It is the case for the SACP wall to wall contestation of the Local Government Elections. In pursuit of working class representation especially in policy formulation space and parliamentary transcripts the SACP is justified to contest the upcoming Local Government Elections.
The so called “highly complex modern Government of National Unity” was a unilateral decision that did not only mark a class suicide by our liberation movement but also constituted what Dr Zamani says its “hand power to right wing, counter revolutionary opposition formations”. He co-governs the Northern Cape with the Freedom Front Plus to start with and it is so easy to consult the class adversary force than his own comrades in the alliance. Is this perhaps not this very “coalition enthusiasm” phenomenon gaining traction? We ought to emphasize that the signing of the statement of intent was a unilateral action.
The commitment to neoliberal economic policy trajectory sponsored by the Havard Scholars is not a myth and therefore it would not be easy to dispel without facts or by merely citing the social security net, NHI and BELA Acts. It is expressed and further buttressed through austerity measures of selling state assets, cutting on public or social spending and the prioritization of the international debts. The recent economic recovery programme sought to further auction parastatals like Eskom and Transnet. Our comrades call this phenomenon fiscal discipline while labeling us as intellectually lazy and dishonest.
The Writing is on the Wall- the SACP contest Wall to Wall!
The Wall to Wall Contestation by the SACP as announced by the General Secretary confirming 4418 candidates of the SACP is critically important for the rescue mission of the NDR in the interest of the primary motive forces being the working class. This is the vanguard role of the Communist Party. The General Secretary announced that the SACP candidates are composed of the advanced detachment of the working class in the SACP cadre ship, traditional leaders, religious leaders, partners in the Conference of the Left among other social partners. It is rather embarrassing and exposes the motive for cheap political point scoring to suggest that SACP candidates are made of those who could not “make the cut” in ANC processes. Sheer desperation to say the least.
The SACP through its General Secretary, the thought of Cde Solly Mapaila, on the 6th January 2026, Joe Slovo Commemoration was emphatic that SACP is not” going it alone”.It is going with and towards the people in the interest of the people by the people. The candidates list of the SACP is foolproof to this fact. Not thumb-sucking. This narrative was confirmed by the speakers in the very gathering from youth and students, religious associations, women and veterans organizations, traditional leaders, Hostel associations etc.
It is rather distasteful, leaves a bitter taste and does not auger well for a senior leader of the ANC of the stature of Dr Zamani to characterize the leadership which is the outcome of congress as an “ultra-left clique” that has captured the Party. Sitting on the ANC NEC, one wonders whether this is the official position of the ANC on the SACP. The SACP has show cased the people centred and oriented attitude towards resolution of gist of the problem for food security and sovereignty through a food production programme of the SACP. Seeking to address the issue of property relations in society perfoming its vanguard contrary to what Zamani may wish to be a popular view.
The People’s red Caravan flagship programme of the SACP anchored on self-reliance and self-sufficiency is a model developed for grassroots mobilization and community development. This work takes place while the SACP is working with the people and not what the good Dr titled “cooption by capital”. It is becoming more vivid to us, the causes of the non-implementation of the resolution 1 of 2018 because the good Dr as a leading academic and theoretician believes the worker leaders in government are just but “Salaried Civil Servants”.
The SACP has also demonstrated class allegiance, maturity, tolerance and nonpartisan behavior by convening the conference of the left that was both a resounding success and watershed conference for the class.
Over and above the unification and renewal of the class, it also produced a common analysis of the state of the revolution from the working class perspective.
Common programme to confront;
- Land reform and redistribution through expropriation of land without compensation, the land referendum, focus on amendments of the Prevention of illegal eviction act, the support for the equitable access act.
- The urgency of the struggle for free , quality, decolonized education.
- The Support for the campaign of full and immediate implementation of the National Health Insurance.
- Progressive Internationalism and advocancy of the Cuba International Solidarity Act.
- Basic Services Campaign to address economic transformation guargmire of macro-economic policy.
- To campaign for the introduction of industrial policy that creates jobs by investing in productive sectors.
The Writing is on the Wall.
The SACP will contest 2026 LGE Wall to Wall.
On occasion of the 105 years anniversary of the SACP, it proceeded to launch its 2026 Local Government Elections Manifesto that constituted a social contract between the people, the class and its vanguard- the South African Communist Party.
The Writing is on the Wall- SACP is contesting Wall to Wall.
The SACP is independently and actively contesting 2026 LGE to deepen class consciousness and seek to resolve the crisis of working class representation in society which includes youth and women representation.
Forward to State Power for Forward to People’s Power!
Finally!
The People shall Truly Govern!


