Skip to content
The People's
Register
Reporting. Analysis. Public information.
Menu

Ideas & History · Angela Davis

Angela Davis and the unfinished work of abolition

Abolition demands more than fewer prison cells. Davis’s arguments also require answers about immediate protection, the limits of reform and the evidence for alternatives.

In Are Prisons Obsolete?, Angela Davis declines to nominate one institution that could simply take the prison’s place. Her proposal is a connected set of changes in education, health care and justice, directed towards reducing imprisonment. A replacement that preserves confinement through another name or technology would leave the central problem intact. [1]

This changes the burden of argument. A prison concentrates several claims in a single building: punishment, protection, accountability and the management of people whom other institutions have failed. Abolition requires those claims to be separated. Some harms may be prevented through social provision; some crises need specialised assistance; some acts require an immediate protective response. A credible alternative must show which function it can perform, whose freedom it increases and what happens when it fails.

What the prison makes disappear

Davis’s 1998 essay Masked Racism argues that imprisonment can remove people from public view while leaving unemployment, homelessness and other social problems unresolved. Her account of a prison-industrial complex includes construction, finance, communications, services and labour, alongside private prison operators. It describes relationships between public authority and commercial interests, rather than treating privately owned prisons as the whole system. The racial identification of criminality helps make that allocation of resources appear natural. [3]

The explanatory claim is stronger than a denunciation of profit. A system can acquire organised interests in its continuation even when it fails to achieve the purpose offered to the public. Budgets sustain jobs, contracts and professional authority. Those interests can make expansion politically easier than investment in less punitive institutions. The resulting question concerns how a social need is translated into a particular funded response, and how that response acquires defenders of its own.

Davis also describes a cycle in which punishment consumes resources while impoverishment remains. Her historical essay supplies a political interpretation of that relationship. It does not, by itself, establish that every increase in a prison budget caused an equivalent cut to a social programme, or that commercial profit explains every penal decision. Those stronger causal claims would need evidence about particular budgets, institutions and decisions. [3]

For a South African reader, this distinction prevents a ready-made American explanation from replacing local investigation. The useful question is how a punitive response becomes organised and financed in a particular society. An anti-capitalist account gains precision by identifying the relationships through which resources and power move. Merely naming a complex cannot substitute for showing those relationships, and exposing them does not settle every question about protection from serious harm.

Equality can extend a punitive norm

In Public Imprisonment and Private Violence, also published in 1998, Davis connects punishment within the household to punishment by the state. She challenges the separation of women into the apparently exclusive categories of victim and offender. A woman subjected to intimate violence may also face imprisonment; treating the two experiences as unrelated can obscure the power operating through both. [4]

Her argument becomes particularly sharp when she examines demands for equality between women’s and men’s prisons. Discussing a former Michigan warden’s account, Davis shows how parity could mean additional weapons and more coercive security practices. The male prison had become the standard against which improvement was measured. Equal treatment could therefore expand a punitive norm instead of questioning it. [4]

This is a precise objection to a particular model of reform. If an institution’s existing standard is harmful, extending it more evenly cannot be assumed to emancipate anyone. Yet the reverse conclusion would also be wrong: people confined now should not be denied better food, health care or protection from abuse because such gains fall short of abolition. The test is the direction of the change. Does it reduce a harm and the power producing it, or make that power easier to defend and extend?

That test requires listening to imprisoned people as political participants. An improved service can be necessary while a larger institutional settlement remains unacceptable. A campaign need not pretend that the first gain completes the struggle. Nor should the prospect of a transformed society become a reason to leave people suffering in the present. The tension between immediate relief and structural change is part of the work, not an inconsistency that a slogan can dissolve.

The objection abolition has to answer

The 2001 joint statement by INCITE! and Critical Resistance confronts this tension from inside the movement. It criticises reliance on policing and imprisonment, but also admits that anti-prison organising has failed to answer adequately how serious interpersonal violence should be addressed. It warns against romantic accounts of community and calls for mechanisms that protect survivors and establish accountability. Davis appears among the statement’s supporters; it is a collective document, not her sole-authored argument. [5]

The objection is concrete. Someone exposed to an ongoing threat cannot be asked to wait for social transformation. A survivor also cannot be required to forgive, negotiate with an abuser or trust a community leader who has an interest in preserving the perpetrator’s standing. Protection must include a meaningful ability to refuse contact. Accountability requires consequences that do not depend on the goodwill of the person responsible for harm. Any system claiming to provide these needs procedures, resources and scrutiny.

Davis closes Are Prisons Obsolete? with the reconciliation between Amy Biehl’s parents and men convicted of their daughter’s killing in South Africa. The example demonstrates a possibility beyond permanent enmity. It cannot establish that reconciliation is available in every case, or supply a complete institutional response to an unwilling or continuing perpetrator. The gap between an illuminating case and a general system remains. [1]

This limitation does not vindicate every practice of the existing prison system. The same questions should be asked of it: whether people are protected, whether harms recur, whether punishment creates further injury and whether those harmed receive material support. The comparison must concern actual capacities and effects on both sides. A defective existing institution cannot demand perfection from an alternative while treating its own failures as unavoidable.

A bounded experiment, not a complete answer

A 2022 study by Thomas Dee and Jaymes Pyne offers a narrow example of such assessment. It examined Denver’s six-month STAR pilot in 2020, which sent a mental health clinician and paramedic to selected nonviolent calls. Comparing changes across participating and other precincts, the researchers estimated a 34% reduction in police-recorded targeted offences and no detectable effect on more serious offences. This was a quasi-experiment, not a randomised trial. [6]

The measurement matters. The authors distinguished fewer incidents being classified as crimes from reductions in underlying offending, and could not exactly separate their contributions. Calls with evidence of weapons, threats, violence or serious medical need were screened out. The study therefore supports a bounded claim about responding differently to selected crises. It does not test a complete abolitionist programme, establish an answer to serious violence or guarantee the same results elsewhere. [6]

The example gives institutional substance to a question that can otherwise remain abstract. A different response can be described through its staff, eligibility rules and observed results. Its limits can be stated without denying its value. Further claims then require further evidence. This is a productive relationship between a radical political aim and practical inquiry: the aim directs attention towards neglected possibilities, while the evidence limits what may honestly be claimed for each one.

Davis’s challenge is ultimately about the social organisation of freedom. Closing a prison door is not sufficient if coercion is transferred into a home, clinic or surveillance system. Conversely, building care is not sufficient if those facing immediate harm remain unprotected. Abolition makes its strongest demand when it joins the redistribution of resources to a refusal to abandon either group. Its unfinished work is to make safety materially available without making another population disposable.

About the desk

Analysis and public scholarship

The News Desk reports and analyses public affairs, science, culture and history for The People’s Register.

Profile and published work →
Sources and further reading
  1. Angela Y. Davis, Are Prisons Obsolete? (2003) (opens in a new tab) Primary argument and concluding example, not proof that one alternative addresses every form of harm.
  2. UC Santa Cruz, Angela Y. Davis faculty biography (opens in a new tab) Official biography and academic affiliation.
  3. Angela Davis, Masked Racism: Reflections on the Prison Industrial Complex, ColorLines (Fall 1998) (opens in a new tab) Historically situated primary essay. Its dated numerical claims and company examples are not presented as current facts.
  4. Angela Y. Davis, Public Imprisonment and Private Violence: Reflections on the Hidden Punishment of Women (1998) (opens in a new tab) Primary feminist analysis. The warden example is attributed through Davis’s reading of that account.
  5. INCITE! and Critical Resistance, Statement on Gender Violence and the Prison Industrial Complex (2001) (opens in a new tab) Collective primary statement; its historical admissions are not treated as a survey of every contemporary abolitionist proposal.
  6. Thomas S. Dee and Jaymes Pyne, A community response approach to mental health and substance abuse crises reduced crime (2022) (opens in a new tab) Quasi-experimental evidence about selected Denver calls in 2020. Police-recorded offences, scope and uncertainty are explicitly distinguished.

Request a correction · Editorial standards