Skip to content
The People's
Register
Reporting. Analysis. Public information.
Menu

Ideas & History · Care, labour and emancipation

Nancy Fraser and the work a free society must learn to share

The promise of equal opportunity is incomplete if necessary care remains unequally assigned. Reading Nancy Fraser alongside South African time-use evidence changes how we judge work, welfare and emancipation.

In South Africa’s 2010 Time Use Survey, female respondents averaged 195 minutes a day on household maintenance, compared with 88 minutes for male respondents. The figures cover respondents aged ten and above, including those who did none of the activity that day. They describe an unequal distribution of necessary work. They also expose a problem for accounts of economic contribution that begin and end with paid employment. [1]

What happens to a promise of equality if the working day expands but responsibility for maintaining life stays where it was? Nancy Fraser’s work helps explain why a job, a care allowance and a public service can each improve someone’s position while leaving other relations of dependence intact. The challenge is to organise earning, caring and political participation so that freedom in one sphere does not depend on another person’s subordination.

The economy depends on work it does not fully recognise

In Behind Marx’s Hidden Abode, published in 2014, Fraser proposes an expanded account of capitalism. Market exchange and wage labour depend on conditions they cannot themselves simply supply: social reproduction, political institutions and the natural world. Social reproduction includes care, education, the maintenance of relationships and the formation of future generations. Some occurs within households, some in public institutions and some through paid employment. It is therefore broader than unpaid housework. [3]

Her central move is to treat the boundaries between these activities as political and historical. The separation of production from reproduction helps organise gendered power, even though the two remain dependent on each other. A theory that treats only the wage relation as economically consequential misses this dependence. The question is not whether care has become completely commercialised. Capitalism can depend on activities that remain outside markets, including forms of household provision that help sustain low-paid labour. [3]

Consider an employer whose schedule assumes that someone else will always collect children, prepare food and care for an ill relative. That assumption may be convenient for the firm, but its costs have not disappeared. They have been assigned elsewhere. The arrangement can remain individually workable for an employee with enough money to hire help, while becoming unmanageable for an employee who cannot. A shared workplace rule can therefore produce very different burdens.

Fraser sharpens the contradiction in her 2016 interview with Sarah Leonard. A society can increase demands for paid work while reducing support for the relationships and activities that make such work possible. The resulting strain is structural, rather than a collection of personal failures to manage time. Her account also warns against a nostalgic solution: earlier arrangements that supported some households could depend on gender hierarchy and exclusions along racial or national lines. [4]

Two reforms, two incomplete freedoms

Fraser’s 1994 essay After the Family Wage compares two deliberately idealised alternatives. Universal breadwinning would support women’s employment, including through services that make employment possible. Caregiver parity would support informal care through allowances and social protections. She tests both against several dimensions of gender equity, including poverty, exploitation, income, leisure, respect and participation. Neither model succeeds completely: securing income does not necessarily redistribute care, while supporting care does not necessarily end women’s separation from wider public life. [5]

Her alternative requires men to undertake care and institutions to accommodate people who both earn and care. She envisages shorter working time, services, supported informal care and forms of provision beyond the conventional nuclear household. These are elements of a thought experiment about radical reform, rather than an evaluation of an implemented programme. Its force lies in changing the institutional standard, instead of expecting women alone to adapt to it. [5]

The comparison helps separate three questions that a single employment target cannot answer. Has someone gained income? Has their total workload become more manageable? Can they influence decisions outside work and home? An intervention might improve the first while worsening the second and leaving no time for the third. This matters to democracy as well as to household welfare: the formal right to attend a meeting is thin protection when necessary care makes attendance impossible.

A care allowance presents a different tension. It could reduce dependence on a partner and recognise an essential contribution. But if its design assumes that women will provide the care indefinitely, it could stabilise the very division of responsibility that restricts them. The relevant judgement concerns both immediate security and future choices. A reform need not solve every injustice to be worthwhile, but its direction should be visible.

What the South African evidence can establish

The 2010 survey describes time allocation; it does not test Fraser’s complete theory. Its retrospective twenty-four-hour diaries distinguished household maintenance from care of persons. Averages across all respondents differ from averages only among participants. These are historical observations, not measurements of today’s workloads. Their value here is to make otherwise neglected work visible. [1]

The survey classifies unpaid household work as productive while placing it outside the production boundary used for national accounts. That exclusion does not make the activity unimportant. Conversely, a monetary estimate would not settle who should pay, who should provide care or how its quality should be judged. [1]

Those choices require evidence about local conditions. A service’s opening hours may fit a conventional working day but exclude workers on shifts. Transport time may make an apparently nearby facility difficult to use. Moving a task out of the household may relieve one person while imposing poorly supported work on another. These are possible mechanisms to investigate, not conclusions supplied automatically by a national average.

The worker providing the care must remain in view

The International Labour Organization’s 2018 care report brings paid and unpaid work into the same discussion. Its evidence describes care workers who are frequently women, migrants or workers in informal employment, often facing low pay and poor conditions. The report argues that reducing and redistributing unpaid care must be joined to decent conditions for paid carers. It treats the quality of care and the quality of care employment as connected objectives. [6]

The report’s headline estimates require their own boundaries. Its calculation of unpaid care hours draws on data from 64 countries covering roughly two-thirds of the world’s working-age population. Its estimates of additional jobs by 2030 are investment scenarios, not jobs already created. These distinctions matter because the political case for care can survive without turning an estimate into a certainty. A strong case identifies what resources and changes would be needed for the proposed benefit. [6]

Buying care cannot, on its own, settle the distributional problem. A professional household may gain time through a paid worker whose own care responsibilities remain unsupported. The improvement for one household is real, but an assessment of emancipation cannot stop at its front door. Wages, hours, security and voice for the person providing care belong inside the same judgement as access for the person receiving it.

In the Leonard interview, Fraser rejects the suggestion that emancipatory care requires doing everything privately or by hand. She defends a society’s capacity to decide collectively what should be organised through public provision, households or other arrangements. Her aim is to place the conditions of sustaining life within democratic discussion, alongside the organisation of paid production. This keeps the question open to different practical solutions while refusing to treat inherited arrangements as natural. [4]

A serious objection: recognition does not provide the service

Fraser’s framework diagnoses a relationship; it cannot substitute for the work of designing and funding a dependable institution. Care differs across ages, needs and relationships. Some tasks can be shared or reorganised; others depend on continuity and trust. An under-resourced public service may transfer time back to households through queues and repeated journeys. Calling the provision collective does not establish that it is accessible, humane or accountable.

The answer is to make institutional responsibility specific. A proposal should identify the work involved, the people expected to perform it, the resources available and the routes for challenging failures. Those receiving care need a voice alongside the workers providing it. A family’s preference also requires interpretation: choosing care at home carries a different meaning when a dependable alternative exists than when no alternative is available.

This approach changes how reform is judged. A programme can relieve immediate hardship while creating conditions for a wider redistribution of responsibility. Secure employment for carers, usable services and working time compatible with care can reinforce one another. The test is whether the arrangement expands people’s practical choices and reduces dependence on another person’s unchecked discretion. That requires sustained organisation and public resources, not a celebration of private endurance.

The care question therefore reaches the centre of political economy. Every programme of development presupposes people who are fed, supported, taught and able to participate in social life. Treating that work as a private reserve allows its demands to disappear from public debate while remaining fully present in people’s days. A more emancipatory order would make the responsibility visible, share it more fairly and give those who carry it a consequential voice in deciding how society uses its time.

About the desk

Analysis and public scholarship

The News Desk reports and analyses public affairs, science, culture and history for The People’s Register.

Profile and published work →
Sources and further reading
  1. Statistics South Africa, A survey of Time Use, 2010 (opens in a new tab) Historical survey. Figure 3.2 reports averages across all respondents, including non-participants.
  2. The New School, Nancy Fraser faculty profile (opens in a new tab) Institutional biography and bibliography.
  3. Nancy Fraser, Behind Marx’s Hidden Abode (2014) (opens in a new tab) New Left Review 86, March–April 2014. See the distinction between the economy and its background conditions.
  4. Sarah Leonard interviews Nancy Fraser, Capitalism’s Crisis of Care (2016) (opens in a new tab) Dissent, Fall 2016. Fraser explains the argument and its political implications.
  5. Nancy Fraser, After the Family Wage: Gender Equity and the Welfare State (1994) (opens in a new tab) Political Theory 22(4), pp. 591–618. A comparison of idealised arrangements and their limits.
  6. International Labour Organization, Calls for Urgent Action in Care Economy (2018) (opens in a new tab) Summary of Care work and care jobs for the future of decent work. The 2030 employment figures describe scenarios, not observed outcomes.

Request a correction · Editorial standards