Skip to content
The People's
Register
Reporting. Analysis. Public information.
Menu

Ideas & History · Colonialism, clinical knowledge and institutional freedom

Fanon, medicine and the power to define a patient

A failed experiment at an Algerian psychiatric hospital forced Fanon and a colleague to examine their own assumptions. The episode illuminates both his anti-colonial method and its limits.

In 1954, Frantz Fanon and Jacques Azoulay published an account of failure. At Blida-Joinville psychiatric hospital in Algeria, social activities they reported as successful among European women had failed among Muslim men. Meetings dragged; the hospital newspaper barely involved the men; entertainments did not generate the expected participation. The clinicians eventually turned the question back on themselves. They had attempted to transplant a particular social world into the ward and treated its failure as the patients’ problem. [1]

The reversal is the intellectual centre of the episode. An institution can create the conditions that prevent people from participating, then interpret their non-participation as evidence of incapacity. Professional benevolence offers no immunity against that mistake. Read alongside Fanon’s writing on racial experience and colonial medicine, the paper raises a demanding problem: how can expertise understand a person without first forcing that person into the categories through which the institution already governs?

When a category gets there first

In the 1952 essay The North African Syndrome, Fanon examines how medical staff in France could dismiss North African patients whose suffering did not yield the expected physical explanation. The supposed syndrome was transmitted through professional assumption, rather than established through investigation. His response enlarges the inquiry to the patient’s situation: work, insecurity, relationships and history. It challenges the leap from an unlocated cause to an accusation that the patient is pretending. [4]

Two different claims must remain separate. A report of suffering deserves serious attention. The explanation for that suffering still requires investigation. Rejecting a prejudiced explanation does not establish a complete alternative diagnosis. The methodological force of the essay lies in preventing uncertainty from becoming a licence to stop listening. Once a group is classified as inherently unreliable, disagreement with the clinician can be absorbed as further evidence of unreliability. The explanation protects itself from correction.

Black Skin, White Masks approaches this closure through lived experience. In its fifth chapter, Fanon describes the disruption of an ordinary bodily relation to the world by a racialising gaze. The body becomes something watched and judged from outside. The person is made to carry a collective history of stereotypes before acting or speaking. Fanon’s first-person narration moves between encounters, philosophical argument and a struggle over self-description. It does not offer a representative sample of all Black experience; it exposes what an abstract declaration of human equality can fail to perceive. [5]

The distinction is between being formally included in a category of human beings and being encountered as someone whose account can matter. An official assurance of equality cannot, by itself, undo a relation in which one side retains the power to define the other’s meaning. That is why an appeal to neutral procedure needs scrutiny. A procedure becomes less neutral when its classifications prevent some participants from supplying evidence that could alter the result.

What the ward comparison can show

Fanon and Azoulay revised their activities around forms of sociability familiar to patients, including a café, religious festivities and storytelling. They reported growing involvement. Yet the comparison placed European women beside Muslim men, confounding cultural background with sex and other differences. Their paper also made sweeping claims about Muslim social life and suitable work for men and women. Its self-criticism did not eliminate the risk of replacing one rigid picture of the patient with another. [1]

This limitation is central to the argument. Cultural attention can interrupt assimilation, but it can also become a refined instruction about who a person is supposed to be. There is no logical reason to assume that a practice familiar within a community is desired by every member. A patient must remain able to differ from the cultural description offered on their behalf. Otherwise the institution has changed the content of its classification while retaining its power to make classification final.

Alice Cherki, who worked with Fanon, supplies a useful restraint on retrospective triumph. In an interview conducted in 2022 and published in Radical Philosophy in 2026, she recalls patients engaging in activities and emphasises that the changes concerned particular services, not the entire hospital. She does not claim to remember which individual patients were discharged. She also recalls an approach in which a patient might establish a meaningful connection with a secretary rather than a doctor. Expertise remained, but formal professional rank did not dictate every valuable relationship. [6]

Her distinction between remembered participation and unremembered discharge matters. A more bearable institutional life is a substantial achievement on its own terms. It is nevertheless different from demonstrating recovery, identifying which intervention caused it or establishing how long it lasted. Neither an admiring witness nor a hostile reader should collapse those measures. The evidence can support a claim about changes in interaction while leaving stronger therapeutic conclusions unresolved.

There is also a reason to resist the heroic version of institutional change. If success is credited entirely to an exceptional clinician, the account can reproduce the very hierarchy it celebrates him for disturbing. The harder task is to describe which relationships changed, how other staff participated, and what patients themselves could initiate. Those are the features through which an experiment can become intelligible to someone who was not present to witness its founder.

Trust has a material history

Medicine and Colonialism, a chapter of A Dying Colonialism, moves beyond the ward. Fanon describes medical encounters embedded in conquest, policing and unequal power. He also recognises that sharing the patient’s origins does not automatically make a doctor trustworthy. His account of the liberation struggle describes efforts to obtain medicines and organise care, followed by changes in people’s relation to medical techniques. The argument concerns the political relationship through which a technique is offered, rather than an intrinsic opposition between Algerians and medicine. [7]

This changes the meaning of distrust. It may involve mistaken beliefs, but describing it solely as a deficit of information leaves the institution itself outside the inquiry. A service can ask people to accept its knowledge while imposing conditions that make acceptance costly or frightening. Explaining a technique cannot resolve every conflict over who controls it, who can obtain it or what obligations receiving it creates. Those questions concern power and material access as well as communication.

Fanon’s chapter can itself become too absolute. Its contrast between colonial mistrust and the solidarity of revolutionary care leaves little room for disagreement or disappointment within the liberation movement. The narrative reports transformed relations and public-health achievements, but does not establish a controlled account of outcomes. Its confidence about revolutionary transformation should therefore be read as part of an intervention in an ongoing struggle, rather than as a completed evaluation of a health system. [7]

The objection does not require separating care from politics. It requires holding an emancipatory institution to the freedom it promises. Political commitment cannot settle whether an intervention works, and identification with a movement cannot replace a person’s consent. An institution that regards criticism as betrayal may become unable to hear the evidence necessary to improve. The danger persists even when the people directing it have fought real oppression.

Reading these works together gives a precise conception of institutional freedom. People need access to knowledge and services, but also standing to challenge the account an institution makes of them. Neither professional expertise nor cultural identification can substitute for that standing. The right to be heard must include the possibility that the institution, its categories and its practice will change. That is the demanding political content of taking a patient seriously.

About the desk

Analysis and public scholarship

The News Desk reports and analyses public affairs, science, culture and history for The People’s Register.

Profile and published work →
Sources and further reading
  1. Frantz Fanon and Jacques Azoulay, Social therapy in a ward of Muslim men: Methodological difficulties (1954), in Alienation and Freedom (opens in a new tab) A 1954 co-authored clinical account that records the authors’ own methodological failures.
  2. Bibliothèque nationale de France, Frantz Fanon authority record (opens in a new tab) National-library confirmation of dates and hospital appointments.
  3. University of Wuppertal, Marie Cravageot on Frantz Fanon (opens in a new tab) University account of Fanon’s education, writing and political commitments.
  4. Frantz Fanon, The North African Syndrome (1952), in Toward the African Revolution (opens in a new tab) Fanon’s 1952 critique of prejudgement in the clinical encounter.
  5. Frantz Fanon, Black Skin, White Masks, chapter 5: The Lived Experience of the Black Man (opens in a new tab) Fanon’s account of racialisation as lived bodily experience.
  6. Alice Cherki and Lucie Kim-Chi Mercier, Fanon’s social therapy (opens in a new tab) A colleague’s retrospective testimony, including the limits of what she remembers.
  7. Frantz Fanon, A Dying Colonialism (1959), chapter 4: Medicine and Colonialism (opens in a new tab) Fanon’s wartime argument about medicine, distrust and national liberation.

Request a correction · Editorial standards