Ideas & History · Steve Biko
Steve Biko and the power to speak for ourselves
Black Consciousness challenged the authority to define other people’s freedom. Its institutional history also shows why an independent voice must be able to question its own leaders.
Steve Biko’s account of an argument over apartheid’s permit rules contains an unexpected turn. At a student gathering, he recalled, Black delegates challenged white participants’ authority to decide whether Africans should defy a restriction on their presence in a white area. When the Black delegates met separately, they chose to comply with the rule and move on to their own organising. Independent deliberation did not automatically produce the most confrontational decision. It changed who could make it. [1]
That distinction opens a more exact reading of Black Consciousness. The issue is not whether every decision made autonomously will be wise or militant. It is whether people subjected to domination can become political authors, including authors of strategy, without having their judgement continually supervised by others. This is a struggle over the organisation of power, not simply an improvement in self-esteem. Its promise, and its difficulties, become visible when the argument is followed into institutions.
Integration on whose terms?
In Black Souls in White Skins?, published under the name Frank Talk in the August 1970 SASO Newsletter, Biko challenged the assumption that a racially mixed organisation necessarily embodied equality. People could enter it carrying the authority and deference produced by segregation. He distinguished admission into an unchanged white social order from participation in a society whose values and direction everyone could help determine. Autonomous Black organisation was, in this argument, a condition for meaningful integration. [3]
The argument concerns a difference between a seat and a share of authority. An institution can admit someone while retaining control over which questions may be asked, which manner of speaking sounds intelligent and which demands count as reasonable. Under those conditions, inclusion can recruit witnesses to the institution’s generosity while leaving its power intact. The excluded person’s presence becomes evidence of progress before that person has acquired the power to define what progress would mean.
Biko’s polemic also generalised sharply about whites as beneficiaries of a common privilege. Its claim that segregation was not a natural order sits beside its sweeping account of white motives. These are different propositions: a shared structural advantage can be demonstrated without proving that every beneficiary thinks alike. His strongest argument concerns the unequal relations reproduced inside an organisation, rather than a presumed ability to read every participant’s conscience. [3]
This qualification does not require the oppressed to seek permission for independent organisation. It makes the justification more defensible. People need the capacity to formulate interests and choose representatives without having to establish that every possible ally is insincere. Solidarity then involves accepting the limits of one’s authority as well as offering assistance. The desire to help does not confer a right to lead.
Race, class and the terms of a common struggle
In his October 1972 interview with Gail Gerhart, Biko included Indian and Coloured people within the oppressed political constituency, while recognising differences in the restrictions imposed on them. He also rejected the idea that a socialist economic arrangement would automatically undo inherited hierarchies in education, religion and culture. Economic transformation, on his account, still left work to do on the standards through which human worth was judged. [1]
This is a challenge to a class analysis that treats racial domination as a secondary misunderstanding. Ownership and wages matter, but so do the institutions that decide who is qualified to teach, whose experience becomes knowledge and whose speech is dismissed before it is heard. Conversely, a common experience of racism cannot make the interests of an employer and a worker identical. A politics adequate to liberation must explain their possible solidarity and their possible conflict.
The serious objection is therefore internal as well as external. Once a movement speaks in the name of a unified people, it can treat disagreement as insufficient consciousness. A wealthy supporter, a woman challenging male authority and a worker contesting conditions of employment may all be told that their dispute distracts from unity. The answer cannot be an endless postponement of those differences. An independent political voice has to remain plural enough for people to challenge power within their own organisations.
Ramphele’s test of apparent self-government
Mamphela Ramphele made a related institutional argument in Government Created Platforms, published by Black Community Programmes in 1976. She examined the homeland administrations and other bodies through which the apartheid state offered restricted representation. Her objection concerned the structure of authority: dependence on Pretoria, protected leadership positions, limited elected power and economic arrangements serving cheap labour. Black office-holders could administer institutions that continued to organise Black subordination. [4]
Read alongside Biko, this gives autonomy a demanding content. An organisation is not autonomous merely because its visible officials belong to the people it governs. The location of decision-making power, the resources it controls and the interests its rules protect matter. The parallel also prevents a false equivalence between an oppressed group forming its own organisation and a state imposing separate political enclosures upon it. One seeks the capacity to contest the common order; the other can restrict the field in which contest is permitted.
Ramphele’s essay is a political intervention, not a detached assessment of every participant’s motive. Her case against working through state-created institutions was categorical. Whether a particular tactical intervention could nevertheless secure an immediate gain would require further evidence. The structural criticism retains force without assuming that no oppressed person could ever make a rational calculation about using a constrained platform. [4]
The clinic and the limits of self-reliance
The community programmes give the dispute a material setting. Tricontinental’s archival account records the establishment of Zanempilo Community Health Centre at Zinyoka in January 1975, with Ramphele as its first medical officer. Other doctors later joined. The same history describes the programmes’ connections to Christian organisations, which helped supply resources and office space. Independent Black organisation did not mean that every useful resource had to originate inside an isolated racial community. [5]
A clinic can alter a relationship as well as provide a service. When people excluded from recognised expertise establish a functioning institution, they challenge the claim that they are permanent dependants. But an institution’s symbolic force does not establish the quality or reach of its care. Those require evidence about staffing, treatment, access and patients’ experience. The existence of Zanempilo supports an argument about organised capacity; it should not be inflated into an unmeasured claim about health outcomes.
The programmes were also vulnerable to state power. The historical account records the October 1977 ban on Black Consciousness organisations, the takeover of Zanempilo by the Ciskei administration and the closure of Solempilo before it began operating. The fate of these projects prevents an interpretation in which confidence and initiative alone can overcome the coercive structure around them. [5]
Self-reliance can become a cruel demand when it means that those denied public resources must endlessly replace them with unpaid effort. Its emancipatory meaning has to include the power to claim resources, change their distribution and decide how they are used. A project that depends on a few exhausted organisers may demonstrate courage while remaining fragile. Collective confidence becomes durable when skills, responsibility and the means to sustain the work cease to be the property of a narrow circle.
Biko’s argument survives its own strongest test when autonomy is understood as an expansion of people’s capacity to act, rather than a certificate of purity. The permit dispute, Ramphele’s critique of restricted representation and the community programmes each expose a different way that apparent participation can conceal dependence. A liberated political voice must be able to choose a strategy, command resources and challenge its own representatives. Otherwise the speaker has changed while the terms on which people may speak remain someone else’s property.
Sources and further reading
- Steve Biko interviewed by Gail M. Gerhart, 24 October 1972 (opens in a new tab) Biko’s retrospective account is attributed to him; the conference decision is not presented as an independently verified minute.
- South African History Online, Stephen Bantu Biko (opens in a new tab) South African History Online biography.
- Steve Biko as Frank Talk, Black Souls in White Skins?, SASO Newsletter, August 1970 (opens in a new tab) Original essay published in the August 1970 SASO Newsletter.
- Mamphela Ramphele, Government Created Platforms, in Apartheid: Hope or Despair for Blacks? (1976) (opens in a new tab) Ramphele is treated as an author of political analysis, not merely a supporting figure in Biko’s biography.
- Tricontinental Institute for Social Research, Black Community Programmes (Dossier 44, 2021) (opens in a new tab) An explicitly situated historical account; its institutional facts are not converted into unmeasured health-effect claims.
