Ideas & History · Public Scholarship
Janet Cherry, SalTuba and the meaning of social ownership
Janet Cherry’s work with SalTuba asks whether working-class communities can own the renewable economy being built around them. The experiment reveals why ownership depends on democratic organisation, reliable payment and the public grid.
In 2019, a solar array was installed in a public open space between Sali and Tubali Streets in KwaZakhele. Residents owned the equipment and intended to earn income by selling electricity to the municipal grid. Nelson Mandela University’s 2020 research report records three years of mobilisation, including a community research team that helped select the site. SalTuba began with an organisation and a claim to productive ownership, as well as panels. [1]
A report published in February 2024 for the Presidential Climate Commission described a five-kilowatt pilot feeding the grid without a feed-in tariff. The co-operative had obtained a municipal account and applied to lease the land. Selling through the network to a third party remained part of the proposed route forward. Generating electricity and receiving payment for it were distinct institutional achievements. [2]
This gap gives Janet Cherry’s work its political force. Working-class people can acquire an asset without acquiring the means to turn its output into a dependable livelihood. A democratic energy transition must change their authority over production and the institutions through which production becomes income. SalTuba allows that claim to be examined through decisions about land, contracts, equipment and collective organisation.
An experiment in economic power
Cherry’s account of the Transition Township project describes community researchers surveying household energy use and expenditure. Residents formed a co-operative, elected a committee and participated in positioning the installation. The choice of a raised structure preserved space beneath the panels for collective use. These were practical decisions through which a neighbourhood became involved in shaping a productive asset, rather than simply receiving a service. [7]
The distinction was deliberate. The project aimed to generate income through sales, rather than reduce bills by supplying each home directly. Cherry identified the pilot as a test of institutions governing production and sale, not a test of whether solar technology worked. In her 2025 reflection on activist research, participants appear as researchers, planners and owners, while she recognises the difficulty of connecting local experiments to changes in public policy. [7] [3]
That method has an important strength: attempting to build the alternative exposes obstacles that a proposal can leave abstract. It also creates an obligation to distinguish an experiment’s ambition from its results. An installation can demonstrate that residents are able to organise without demonstrating a durable income stream. A shared decision at the outset does not establish how power will be exercised when revenues, maintenance costs or disagreements arise.
The 2024 report recorded lighting, charging, internet access, recycling activity and a place to study during electricity interruptions at the SalTuba site. These benefits deserve recognition in their own terms. A useful shared facility, an income paid to the co-operative and a reduction in household electricity bills are three different outcomes. Evidence of one cannot stand as proof of the other two. [2]
From a buyer to a payment
In a 31 July 2025 investigation, Oxpeckers journalists Lindiwe Pakati and Thabo Molelekwa reported a ten-year electricity purchase agreement with PowerX, dating the deal to 2022. Engineer Khaled El-Jabi described payments varying with the time electricity was generated. Municipal adviser David Breitfeld said smart-meter installation was imminent. He also explained that the array did not sit behind residents’ household meters, so its generation did not directly reduce their bills. [4]
The reports do not provide a complete chronology from contract to operation. The 2024 account still proposed third-party sales, while the later investigation dated the agreement to 2022. Cherry’s earlier chapter also described a monitoring meter installed in 2019. That history prevents treating the 2025 metering requirement as the first connection. None of these accounts establishes when regular payments began or what members receive today. [2] [7] [4]
Institutions allocate the cost of waiting. A co-operative may need to maintain equipment and administer an organisation before its sales produce usable cash. If members must cover that interval through unpaid work, a project can appear inexpensive by leaving their contribution outside its accounts. If a grant covers it, that support is part of the model that another neighbourhood would need to reproduce.
This is not an argument that a grant-funded experiment must immediately pay for itself. Research and shared services can justify public spending without a private investment return. It is an argument for identifying what the spending achieves. Learning how to establish a co-operative, creating a local service and financing a household income are legitimate but different purposes, with different costs and evidence of success.
What makes ownership social?
The conceptual dispute sharpened in the June 2026 New Agenda. Katrina Lehmann-Grube, Julia Taylor and Khwezi Mabasa question definitions of social ownership so broad that almost any arrangement can qualify. They include Cherry and colleagues’ report in that discussion, while noting that its list excludes individual ownership. They distinguish legal title, operational control and access to benefits, then propose four criteria for social ownership: collective ownership, public benefit, democracy and solidarity. [5]
The distinction prevents a dividend from being mistaken for control. A community may receive income while decisive powers remain elsewhere. Conversely, employing a private technical contractor need not surrender the purpose or direction of a co-operative. The relevant relationship is between the people who can make decisions and the people whose lives those decisions affect. The authors offer a framework for examining that relationship, not a finding that SalTuba has failed it. [5]
The International Cooperative Alliance’s principles give this democratic promise a more specific form: members control the organisation, elected representatives answer to them, and external agreements must preserve that control. Applied to SalTuba, this means technical work can be delegated without making strategic choices inaccessible. Intelligible accounts, authority over spending and a means to replace decision-makers would make ownership effective. These are standards for examining governance, not findings about how SalTuba currently operates. [8]
The Alliance also makes concern for the wider community a co-operative principle. Members may govern their organisation democratically while neighbours remain outside its benefits. A municipality must consider both groups. Calling a project collective identifies its owning body; it does not, by itself, answer how that project serves everyone else. Local control and universal provision are related purposes, but they cannot be assumed to coincide. [8]
The co-operative and the public grid
The PCC’s record of consultations in late 2023 and January 2024 captures a substantial objection: support for new generators may shift costs to other electricity users or weaken municipal revenue. Participants also raised access to capital, the source of subsidies and the years that could pass before dividends arrived. Some called for practical trials to establish which arrangements would work. These concerns place the wider public system inside the evaluation of a local project. [6]
The household outside SalTuba also needs affordable electricity and functioning services. A programme that transfers an asset to one group while passing its costs to poorer neighbours would undermine its claim to justice. Equally, requiring a poor co-operative to finance every public benefit from sales would impose a commercial test on activities supported for their social value. Public policy must state which costs it is supporting, why, and how that support will be shared fairly.
A stronger programme would finance collective generation together with the institutions needed to sustain it: technical assistance, intelligible purchase terms, reliable settlement and a maintained network. Repeating a pilot should not mean repeating years of negotiation over the same administrative problems. The public role is to make a viable route available to successive groups, while keeping both local benefits and costs to the wider system visible.
Cherry’s contribution is to place working-class ownership inside the practical construction of a new energy economy. SalTuba tests the proposition where it is most demanding, among people who cannot solve institutional delay by drawing on private wealth. Its significance lies in showing what a transfer of productive power requires. Panels are one part. The other is an organisation whose members can govern it, supported by public institutions that make their ownership effective without abandoning everyone else.
Sources and further reading
- Nelson Mandela University, Research & Innovation Report 2020, printed p. 60 (opens in a new tab)
- Janet Cherry and colleagues, Social Ownership Models in the Energy Transition, report for the Presidential Climate Commission, February 2024 (opens in a new tab)
- Janet Cherry, Ruth First in the Twenty-First Century: Activist Research in the Age of Climate Change, 2025, pp. 157–158 (opens in a new tab)
- Lindiwe Pakati and Thabo Molelekwa, People who own the sun, Oxpeckers, 31 July 2025 (opens in a new tab)
- Katrina Lehmann-Grube, Julia Taylor and Khwezi Mabasa, Understanding social ownership in context: Towards a just transition in South Africa, New Agenda 101, June 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- Presidential Climate Commission, stakeholder dialogue report on social ownership models, 2024, pp. 4–5 (opens in a new tab)
- Janet Cherry, At the CORE of the (democratic)(energy) transition: A township-based renewable energy project, in South Africa’s Contested Transition to Energy Democracy?, pp. 230–244, especially pp. 237–243 (opens in a new tab)
- International Cooperative Alliance, Statement on the Cooperative Identity, principles on democratic control, autonomy and concern for community (opens in a new tab)
- Rhodes University, Professor Janet Cherry: honorary-degree profile (2023) (opens in a new tab) Institutional account of Cherry’s education, activism, research and doctoral work.
- Nelson Mandela University, Experts Directory: Janet Cherry (opens in a new tab) University directory identification of role, department and research interests.
