Skip to content
The People's
Register
Reporting. Analysis. Public information.
Menu

Ideas & History · Paulo Freire

Paulo Freire and the authority to teach

Teaching for freedom requires knowledge, judgement and material support. It also requires a student’s disagreement to be something the teacher can take seriously.

Paulo Freire uses a pen to distinguish illiteracy from ignorance. In The Importance of the Act of Reading, teacher and learner can both recognise, handle and name the object. The teacher has an additional competence: writing and reading its name. The learner needs help acquiring that competence, but already understands something of the world to which the written word refers. [1]

The distinction places a limit on educational authority. A particular difference in knowledge does not establish a general difference in human worth. It also leaves the teacher with work to do. Recognising a learner’s experience cannot replace teaching a skill the learner wants and does not yet possess. The political difficulty is to organise that unequal relationship so that its result is a greater capacity to act independently, rather than a continuing need for permission.

The learner is a participant in knowledge

In Pedagogy of the Oppressed, Freire’s criticism of banking education concerns a relationship in which the teacher possesses knowledge and learners receive and repeat it. The division becomes absolute: one side knows, the other is defined by its ignorance. His alternative makes the subject being studied available for joint inquiry. Teachers bring material and prior understanding, then reconsider their understanding through students’ responses. [4]

This argument helps distinguish explanation from intellectual dependence. A clear explanation can enable someone to understand a process and examine it further. Repetition becomes a problem when it is the only authorised response, especially when the learner cannot question the categories through which an experience is described. The test concerns what the explanation makes possible. Can the learner use it, investigate its limits and recognise a case in which it does not apply?

Freire’s reading essay also recalls teaching grammar and canonical literature. He wanted students to understand how language worked through meaningful texts, including their own writing. He explicitly defended serious reading of classical authors. His objection was to mechanical memorisation and prescribed quantities of reading detached from comprehension. [1]

There is consequently no useful choice between rigorous knowledge and respect for experience. Experience can reveal what an account misses; it cannot settle every explanation of what happened. A person may understand the daily operation of an institution while needing unfamiliar concepts to investigate its finances or history. Conversely, a technically correct institutional description can leave out how its rules are actually encountered. Education becomes more demanding when those forms of understanding must interrogate one another.

For a working-class movement, that demand has organisational consequences. Political education should increase members’ ability to assess a claim, read a record and follow an argument through its difficult steps. A vocabulary that merely identifies the speaker as politically reliable can conceal dependence on whoever supplies the approved formulation. Class consciousness requires the means to investigate class relations, including the capacity to challenge a reassuring account offered by one’s own leadership.

Authority has work to do

Pedagogy of Freedom makes professional competence indispensable to teaching authority. Freire does not confuse democratic practice with an inability to intervene. He describes a university teacher legitimately stopping a visiting student from disrupting a class. Respect for freedom requires judgement about the conditions in which others can learn; it does not require the teacher to surrender responsibility. [5]

A classroom can be formally open while being effectively controlled by the most confident participants. Someone has to protect the time and standing of those who cannot easily command attention. Exercising that responsibility is an exercise of power. It becomes defensible when its purpose and limits can be explained, when rules apply consistently and when the person exercising it can be questioned. Simply declaring the room democratic provides none of those guarantees.

Freire also distinguishes humility from self-erasure in the fourth letter of Teachers as Cultural Workers. Teaching requires decisions, some taken with students and some arising from the teacher’s professional responsibilities. He connects confidence to competence, political clarity and ethical integrity. Affection for particular students cannot justify violating the rights of others. [6]

These distinctions matter for assessment. The authority to say that an argument is unsupported should not become authority to say that a student’s disagreement is itself a failure. A demanding course can require accurate reading, adequate evidence and coherent reasoning without grading loyalty to its teacher’s conclusions. Students need to know which intellectual achievement is being assessed. Teachers need to distinguish an error they can demonstrate from a political judgement they hope to persuade others to share.

When dialogue becomes conversion

Freire is politically committed. In Pedagogy of Freedom, he rejects both the idea that education simply reproduces dominant ideology and the idea that it can effortlessly undo it. He also insists that criticism requires knowing the work criticised and representing it honestly. Students should encounter teachers who can disagree without falsifying an opponent’s argument. [5]

The objection to his project begins here. A teacher committed to emancipation may believe the destination of every serious discussion is already known. Questions can then become a more tactful means of directing students towards a predetermined answer. A student who resists may be classified as insufficiently critical, even when the resistance concerns evidence or a legitimate difference in judgement. The teacher’s certainty can survive precisely because disagreement is interpreted as proof of the student’s need for further instruction.

Freire’s account of thematic investigation partly anticipates this danger. Participants should help examine and correct specialists’ interpretations; investigators should not impose their own values. Critical understanding cannot be commanded into existence. [4]

That commitment needs a practical test: what could persuade the teacher to change an interpretation? If the answer is nothing, consultation cannot alter the distribution of intellectual power. A credible political education should make its evidence available, distinguish its premises from its conclusions and allow a strong objection to change the discussion. The teacher need not abandon convictions. The convictions must remain answerable to reasons, including reasons offered by people who hold less institutional authority.

This is compatible with taking a clear position against exploitation. An argument about exploitation should explain the relation through which labour, resources or decision-making power are appropriated. Its strength comes from making that relation intelligible and open to investigation. Demanding assent to the right word leaves the underlying relation obscure. Political commitment becomes intellectually stronger when it exposes its explanation to examination, rather than treating its moral purpose as evidence of its accuracy.

The material conditions of teaching

The fourth letter also refuses to make teaching depend on personal sacrifice. Freire links care to struggles over pay, working conditions, freedom to teach and speak, and paid leave for continuing education. He defends the right to criticise educational authorities and recognises that teachers may have to confront their own union leadership. The teacher’s capacity to act ethically has a material and organisational setting. [6]

A system that demands careful preparation, individual attention and continuing study must make time for them. Otherwise its language of dedication can convert a collective obligation into an individual burden. The same applies to students: an invitation to participate has limited force when participation competes with necessities the institution refuses to acknowledge. Democratic education needs arrangements through which both groups can contest the conditions of learning. Good intentions cannot supply those arrangements by themselves.

The texts examined here offer philosophical arguments, professional reflection and recollections of practice. They do not constitute a controlled evaluation establishing that a particular teaching method produces specified literacy gains. Their educational ambitions should not be confused with such a finding. [1] [5] [6]

Freire’s enduring challenge concerns the relation between knowledge and power within a struggle for freedom. A teacher can bring expertise without possessing the learner’s future. A movement can advance an argument without making obedience the measure of understanding. The work succeeds when people acquire capacities they can exercise beyond the approving presence of the teacher, including the capacity to identify where that teacher was wrong.

About the desk

Analysis and public scholarship

The News Desk reports and analyses public affairs, science, culture and history for The People’s Register.

Profile and published work →
Sources and further reading
  1. Paulo Freire, The Importance of the Act of Reading (1983) (opens in a new tab) Primary reflection on reading, literacy and teaching; its recollections are distinguished from an evaluation of educational outcomes.
  2. Pontifical Catholic University of São Paulo, Paulo Freire biography (opens in a new tab) Institutional biography supporting dates, exile and teaching career.
  3. Instituto Paulo Freire, Biografia de Paulo Freire (opens in a new tab) Biographical source for professional formation and international educational work.
  4. Paulo Freire, Pedagogy of the Oppressed, translated by Myra Bergman Ramos (opens in a new tab) Primary argument about banking education and inquiry, including safeguards against imposing investigators’ interpretations.
  5. Paulo Freire, Pedagogy of Freedom: Ethics, Democracy, and Civic Courage (opens in a new tab) Primary account of teaching authority, non-neutral education and ethical disagreement.
  6. Paulo Freire, Teachers as Cultural Workers: Letters to Those Who Dare Teach, Fourth Letter (opens in a new tab) Primary discussion of humility, decision-making, ethical authority and teachers’ material rights.

Request a correction · Editorial standards