Skip to content
The People's
Register
Reporting. Analysis. Public information.
Menu

Ideas & History · Planetary belonging, public institutions and unequal protection

Achille Mbembe: belonging is more than sharing a planet

Living in the same place does not guarantee equal membership. Reading Mbembe alongside a South African constitutional dispute shows why a shared world needs enforceable claims, public institutions and unequal obligations of repair.

In 2004, the Constitutional Court considered the exclusion of permanent residents from South African social assistance. The applicants were Mozambican citizens, most of whom had fled civil war and settled in what became Limpopo. They were destitute and would otherwise have qualified for assistance. Their problem was not absence from the society in which they lived. It was a rule about citizenship. [1]

That distinction offers a concrete way into Achille Mbembe’s thinking. People can share a territory, sustain relationships within it and depend on its institutions while being treated as less entitled to protection. Physical presence does not settle political membership. Nor does recognising that people depend on one another determine how the costs and benefits of that dependence should be distributed.

Mbembe’s 2024 Holberg lecture was framed around the equitable inhabitation of a damaged planet. [2]

The difficult word is shared. It can describe an unavoidable condition, or it can demand a different distribution of power. Moving from the first meaning to the second requires more than an enlarged sense of fellow feeling. It requires institutions through which those exposed to harm can make claims that others must answer.

Inside a society, outside its protection

In his 2003 essay Necropolitics, Mbembe examines sovereignty through the capacity to determine who may live and who is exposed to death. He places slavery and colonial rule within the history of that power. The plantation, in his account, combined a demand for enslaved labour with the destruction of recognised political status and control over the enslaved person’s body. Economic usefulness and political disposability could be produced together. [5]

His discussion of apartheid likewise attends to territory and administration: homelands, townships, restrictions on residence and the organisation of migrant labour. Space was made into a means of governing people’s movement and standing. This is a historical analysis of domination through particular institutions, not simply a claim that powerful people held hostile attitudes. [5]

A serious use of this framework must trace the connection between a classification, the authority applying it and its material consequences. Calling every unfair decision necropolitical would obscure differences between systems of coercion and weaken the argument. The practical question is which decisions make some people’s survival conditional on others’ discretion. [5]

The Khosa judgment provides a distinct example of contested membership, not an application attributed to Mbembe. The majority held that excluding permanent residents from the scheme unjustifiably infringed their rights. Justice Mokgoro weighed the effects on life and dignity against the state’s financial and immigration arguments. Justice Ngcobo’s dissent accepted the exclusion from adult social grants, emphasising fiscal constraints, immigration policy and routes to citizenship, while agreeing that the exclusion concerning children was unjustified. The Court’s remedy covered permanent residents; it did not abolish every distinction between migration statuses. [1]

The dispute makes a political choice visible inside an apparently administrative category. If a person’s need is recognised but their claim is excluded, someone else must absorb the consequences. A demand for solidarity therefore needs an answer to a practical question: what can a person require of an institution, rather than request as a favour? Constitutional litigation is one route to that answer. It cannot replace accessible administration or the organised power needed to hold an institution to its duties.

Interdependence does not distribute power

In a June 2020 conversation with Paul Gilroy at UCL, Mbembe proposed thinking through the connections between human beings and other forms of life. His term bio-symbiosis names an effort to recover those relationships without denying difference. He also urged attention to African intellectual and aesthetic resources that dominant traditions of theory had neglected. These were resources for thinking about a common world, not evidence that all African societies possessed one identical philosophy. [6]

Interdependence alone, however, carries no promise of justice. Two parties may need each other while one controls the terms of their relationship. A worker’s dependence on employment does not give the worker equal power over production. A household’s dependence on water does not give it control over a supplier. The political task is to change how dependence is governed, so that needing others does not become a reason to submit to them.

Mbembe’s lecture for the Prince Claus Fund’s 25th anniversary develops the ecological dimension. He connects the repair of a damaged Earth to a cultural question about which lives and relationships are valued. He argues that culture should not be reduced to an instrument for economic development, and calls for a planetary consciousness attentive to human and other life. The point reaches beyond adding environmental subjects to cultural programmes: it concerns the standards by which a world is considered worth making. [7]

For a public institution, that raises a demanding test. A project can deliver an income while damaging the conditions that allow a community to live there. Evaluating it requires more than adding two columns of money. It requires deciding which losses can be repaired, who has the authority to accept a risk and whether those who benefit can compel others to bear it. Shared life becomes politically meaningful when these questions are opened to collective decision.

A public institution cannot merely offer hospitality

Mbembe’s 2015 lecture on decolonising knowledge makes this problem concrete within the university. He argues that black students and staff should belong by right, rather than depend on an institution’s hospitality or assimilate into an order that treats them as newcomers. The public university appears here as a common good whose ownership and purposes must be contested. Access alone is insufficient if those admitted remain objects of someone else’s benevolence. [8]

Yet his alternative is not a sealed national or racial canon. He draws on African intellectual debates while calling for an open encounter among different traditions of knowledge. He also insists that arguments about the university cannot ignore its political economy, including the need for public funding. Changing who is represented and changing the material conditions of inquiry belong to the same problem. [8]

This gives decolonisation a more exacting task than replacing names on a reading list. Who can afford the time to study? Who can question the methods through which authoritative knowledge is produced? Which languages permit participation? Answers need not dissolve scholarly standards. They should make those standards open to argument and make the capacity to meet them less dependent on inherited advantage. An institution becomes more public when more people can help shape its purposes.

Shared humanity, unequal obligations

The strongest objection to an earthly community is that its scale can erase the very history Mbembe helps us see. If everyone belongs to one vulnerable humanity, a corporation, a displaced household and a wealthy state can appear as equally responsible participants. An appeal to unity can then ask those already carrying the greatest burdens to make another sacrifice. Worse, a planetary authority could present its decisions as universal necessities while making them beyond democratic reach.

That objection should change the proposed politics. Equal standing does not mean equal liability. A right to protection can extend to everyone while the duty to finance it falls differently on those with different resources, benefits and responsibility for harm. Common membership supplies the reason that no group should be abandoned. Historical inquiry supplies the evidence for deciding who owes what. One cannot replace the other without either emptying universality or freezing people into inherited antagonisms.

Resources also impose real choices. A demand for expanded membership is incomplete unless it confronts taxation, staffing, infrastructure and the distribution of decision-making authority. But scarcity should be demonstrated and debated, rather than used as a word that ends the argument. People asked to accept exclusion must be able to examine the priorities that make their protection seem unaffordable. Public budgets are therefore part of the substance of solidarity, alongside legal rights.

Mbembe’s work does not provide a single institutional blueprint that resolves these conflicts. Its value here is to connect the question of belonging to the organisation of life itself. A shared planet becomes a political community through struggles over who may make claims, whose knowledge counts and which obligations survive an encounter with power. The measure is whether people gain the means to contest the conditions under which they must live, and whether those conditions become less dependent on someone else’s permission.

About the desk

Analysis and public scholarship

The News Desk reports and analyses public affairs, science, culture and history for The People’s Register.

Profile and published work →
Sources and further reading
  1. Constitutional Court, Khosa and Mahlaule, [2004] ZACC 11 (opens in a new tab) Judgment of 4 March 2004. The majority and partial dissent concern permanent residents’ access to the specified social-assistance scheme.
  2. Achille Mbembe, The Earthly Community, 2024 Holberg Lecture (opens in a new tab) 5 June 2024.
  3. WiSER, Achille Mbembe (opens in a new tab) WiSER institutional biography, education and historical CODESRIA appointment.
  4. Holberg Prize, Achille Mbembe, 2024 laureate (opens in a new tab) Official 2024 laureate biography and account of Mbembe’s research.
  5. Achille Mbembe, Necropolitics, Public Culture 15(1), 2003 (opens in a new tab) The 2003 essay, especially pp. 11–15 and 21–27. Distinct from the later book bearing the same title.
  6. UCL, Paul Gilroy in conversation with Achille Mbembe (opens in a new tab) Primary conversation, 17 June 2020, on common life, difference and African intellectual resources.
  7. Achille Mbembe, Planetary Consciousness and Possible Future of Culture (opens in a new tab) Lecture for the Prince Claus Fund’s 25th anniversary, published under the title Life.
  8. Achille Mbembe, Decolonizing Knowledge and the Question of the Archive (opens in a new tab) 2015 lecture, especially the discussions of belonging, public institutions and the material conditions of knowledge.

Request a correction · Editorial standards