Skip to content
The People's
Register
Reporting. Analysis. Public information.
Menu

Ideas & History · Race, class and popular power

Walter Rodney and the work of political unity

A party’s socialist guidelines became an instrument workers could turn against their managers. Rodney’s account opens a difficult argument about who gets to direct liberation.

In a 1975 lecture on Tanzania, Walter Rodney described workers carrying pocket copies of their governing party’s guidelines, Mwongozo. They used the document to challenge managers whose conduct contradicted its promises. A text issued from above had become an instrument of argument from below. Rodney’s account turns an apparent administrative problem into a political one: national ownership had not settled who could exercise authority inside the workplace. [1]

This is a demanding place to begin reading Rodney. It prevents anti-imperialism from ending at the transfer of an asset or a flag. It also prevents class analysis from treating workers as a ready-made political subject. People can occupy a similar economic position while lacking the means to act together. The problem is how they acquire those means, and whether organisations claiming to represent them remain open to their independent judgement.

A method that must survive its application

In Marxism and African Liberation, a 1975 speech, Rodney separates Marx’s method from conclusions drawn about nineteenth-century Western Europe. Investigating relations of production does not require every society to repeat a European sequence. His example is Amílcar Cabral: an inquiry into Guinea must begin with the organisation of production, rather than presuming that classes already have the form the investigator expects. Rodney’s claim is that a method can travel while its findings remain historically specific. [3]

That distinction changes what it means to be faithful to a theory. Repeating a conclusion can become a way of refusing the investigation that originally made it persuasive. An analysis earns its authority by identifying a mechanism, showing the evidence for it and remaining vulnerable to a contrary finding. Calling it scientific creates an obligation to do that work. It does not discharge the obligation. A theory able to explain every outcome after the event can otherwise become impossible to test.

Rodney does not consistently preserve this openness in the speech. His treatment of Kwame Nkrumah makes the overthrow of the Ghanaian government a decisive indictment of a political philosophy that had failed to recognise internal class antagonisms. That is a forceful interpretation, but the lecture does not establish how much explanatory weight the philosophical error should carry against other causes of a government’s defeat. The distinction between method and verdict therefore also gives readers a basis for interrogating Rodney. [3]

This is a stronger use of a classic than either reverence or dismissal. A convincing explanation of exploitation need not explain every political reversal by itself. Conversely, evidence that a movement faced powerful external enemies cannot establish that its own decisions were sound. Keeping those propositions separate makes anti-imperialist analysis more exact. It allows solidarity with an emancipatory project to coexist with scrutiny of the people exercising power in its name.

Race does not disappear inside class

The Groundings with My Brothers, first published in 1969, locates Caribbean racial hierarchy within plantation slavery and its aftermath. Rodney follows the movement from African enslavement to Indian indentured labour, refusing to treat the groups’ presence in the Caribbean as unrelated accidents. Yet his defence of Black Power is also a struggle over self-understanding. A formally harmonious national image can conceal degradation. Recovering the right to speak among the oppressed is part of making that degradation contestable. [4]

The difficult question is how common political action can emerge from histories that are connected without being interchangeable. An appeal to unity can become coercive if it requires people to stop naming a particular injury. A movement opposing racial domination must therefore be able to identify unequal treatment within its own constituency. Otherwise its language of common interest gives the least exposed members the power to decide which grievances count as divisive.

In a surviving transcript of a Guyana street speech, Rodney connects racial division to everyday dependence on political power. He names employment, promotion, trade-union leadership and elections as sites where ordinary Afro-Guyanese and Indo-Guyanese could be denied control. He also insists that racial justice remains necessary. His provocation is that sharing a ruler’s racial classification provides no guarantee against that ruler’s coercion. The transcript presents a public intervention, not a neutral survey of everyone’s experience. Its value lies in the political relationship it asks listeners to examine. [5]

The strongest objection is that such an argument can turn racism into a mere disguise for class power. Racial injury can shape trust, memory and vulnerability even where people earn similar wages. A coalition that asks those harmed to disregard that injury may reproduce the domination it promises to overcome. The practical answer must be institutional: common organisation needs explicit protection against unequal treatment, alongside shared control over decisions. Solidarity becomes credible when members can contest injustice within the coalition without being treated as enemies of unity.

Ownership, expertise and the right to disagree

Rodney’s Tanzania lecture supplies a further distinction. In his account, managers could accept nationalisation while resisting workers’ demands over how production was organised. He also criticised the coercive relocation of rural people under the language of socialist development. These were criticisms of a transition he supported. His evidence here combines political observation, examples and interpretation; the lecture is not a systematic comparison of enterprises or villages. Its account should be read as a participant’s diagnosis, not as proof of every outcome of Tanzanian socialism. [1]

Public ownership and popular control answer different questions. Ownership identifies the institution entitled to an asset and its proceeds. Control concerns who can set priorities, obtain information, challenge a decision or remove a representative. Public ownership can make a wider democratic settlement possible, but it cannot specify that settlement on its own. Nor does participation mean that everyone must perform every technical task. The issue is whether technical knowledge becomes a reason to explain decisions or an entitlement to escape explanation.

There is a real problem on the other side. A complex institution needs decisions, coordination and responsibility for failures. Permanent consultation cannot substitute for competence. The democratic task is to assign authority precisely enough that it can be exercised and challenged: who determines a policy, who implements it, what information each must disclose, and how a dispute reaches a decision. Without those distinctions, both managerial command and popular participation can remain declarations with no reliable procedure behind them.

Groundings approaches the problem of expertise through education. Rodney recounts taking discussion outside the university and learning from people whom respectable society treated as ignorant. He retains a contribution of his own, his historical knowledge and analysis, while refusing to make academic status the sole source of understanding. The exchange matters because it changes who can speak authoritatively about a shared world. It is not an instruction to discard study. [4]

The educator’s obligation is consequently double. Knowledge must become available beyond the institution that certifies it, and the encounter must be capable of changing the educator’s account. Listening without that second possibility is consultation as ceremony. Equally, treating experience as beyond examination leaves disagreement unresolved. A serious collective inquiry needs both the knowledge people possess through living a situation and ways of checking interpretations against evidence.

Political unity, on this reading, is an achievement that must be renewed through those practices. Its measure is not how completely a leadership can speak for a people. It is how much capacity people gain to investigate their circumstances, organise across differences and challenge decisions that claim their consent. An anti-imperialist project weakens itself when it exempts its own authority from those demands. Liberation becomes durable when the people invoked as its purpose also possess the means to direct it.

About the desk

Analysis and public scholarship

The News Desk reports and analyses public affairs, science, culture and history for The People’s Register.

Profile and published work →
Sources and further reading
  1. Walter Rodney, Class Contradictions in Tanzania (opens in a new tab) Rodney’s 1975 lecture, read as a participant’s political analysis.
  2. Richard Rathbone, Revolutionary historian: Walter Rodney (1942–1980), SOAS (opens in a new tab) SOAS biographical account by historian Richard Rathbone.
  3. Walter Rodney, Marxism and African Liberation (opens in a new tab) A 1975 speech distinguishing historical method from inherited conclusions.
  4. Walter Rodney, The Groundings with My Brothers (1969; 2014 edition) (opens in a new tab) Rodney’s discussions of racial hierarchy and public education, originally published in 1969.
  5. Walter Rodney, Street Speech, Guyana (public transcript) (opens in a new tab) A public transcript of a Guyana street speech; its exact delivery date is not established here.

Request a correction · Editorial standards